Discuss & Debate | Share | Learn

www.ask.or.tz

Our Partners
Shaykh Muhammad Kamran has been pursuing Islamic Studies at Al Mustafa International University Qom since 2012 and has specialized in the areas of Fiqh and Usool. He also holds a degree in Accounting. He is currently serving as the Head of Academics for the Hussayni Madressa Dar es Salaam.

Moderator: KamranAli

User avatar
By Insaan
#19826
Salamun alaykum
There is a live goat scheme of giving live goats to poor and deserving people to start off livestock farming where one or two male and three female goats are given. In a year these turn into more...so this becomes a source of income for them.
This is normally done in dhulhijja by people who have performed wajib hajj and so are used to sacrificing goats on eid as a mustahab sacrifice after return. This scheme is instead of sacrificing goats.
️ Is it valid and counted as equal to a sacrifice?
️ Can it be done as soon as the month begins as goats become costly at time of sacrifice?
️ Can it be done later after the prices have gone down again?
User avatar
By KamranAli
#19844
1) According to Islamic Traditions it is mustahab to Sacrifice (Slaughter) an animal on Eid ul Adhha. Although giving livestock or cash to the needy people is one of the forms of Sadaqa but it cannot substitute the Recommended Qurbani.

2) Since this act will not be counted as Qurbani. Therefore, it can be given at any time of the year.

mam Hasan al-Askari (عليه السلام) was not merely t[…]

Prophet Muhammad ﷺ was not extraordinary because h[…]

Hazrat Ali Akber A.S

Among all the martyrs of Karbala, Hazrat Ali Akbar[…]

Hazrat Qasim ibn Hassan A.S

Hazrat Qasim (a.s) before going to the battlefield[…]

Ask4help Counseling Helpline