Discuss & Debate | Share | Learn

[mi_sheriff]

Salaams

I have uploaded Ahmed Bukhatir's nasheeds on the link below, many of them are in arabic but are nice and most of them have their translation in english as well.

the links is :
http://www.islamise.co.uk/Nasheeds/Ahmed_Bukhatir.htm

daani nasheed album has some very good english nasheeds such as forgive me
others which are very good are al hejaab in far taqi..

Kh

[Muhammad Mahdi]

nasheeds have musical instruments in them.

Are they halaal?

[abuali]

I think they are not permissible if they have background music as per Aga Sistanis risala (although I am not 100% sure)...therefore I only listen to those that dont have any music with them.

Some in depth research on this would be much appreciated.

If we discover that it is not permissible, we would be better of removing the links to those audio that are not permissible.

[mi_sheriff]

salaams
not al nasheeds have backgroundmusic or musical instruments being played at the back
.. Ahmend bukhatir is one of whom i suggest because all the nasheeds which come from him do not hav back ground music its just his voice n words ... n i guess thts okay ?

bt some reciters like sami yusuf have alot of background music ..
and when i did do some research over a few nasheed reciters i came to discover that some of them were actually music singers or hav a background is some kind of music ...
so it is important that we see who we are lisenting to ..
but with my research ahmed bukhatir doesnt hav any such background but ofcourse u can hav your own research

KH