- 06 Oct 2009, 11:41
#13636
I heard here that Syed. Fadhlollah (one of the Shia great Olemas in Lubnan) has some of the views which Sheikh. Salami has. Syed. fadhlollah has ruled out that:-
-Zanjir is Haraam.
-The shahadah of 'Aliyunwaliullah' is a good bida'h.
-Bibi Zaynab's Hijab was not removed and just the outside covering.
-Mohsen was not killed in the attack of Omar against the house of Zahra (sa).
Now the Moqaledin of Syed. Fadhlollah (among whom is Sheikh Salami) believe these beliefs and we have to respect their beliefs. But Syed. Shirazi (whom many Khojas and Iranians oppose and whom Kuweiti Aarbs follow) ruled out:-
-Zanjir is Sunnah (mustahhab).
-The shahadah of 'Aliyunwaluillah' is Sunnah and a matter of Istihbaab.
-Bibi Zaynab's Hijab was removed.
-Mohsen was killed in the attack of Omar against Syeda Zahra 's house.
As for Syed. khamaenei', he has ruled out that:-
-Zanjir is Haraam.
-The shahadah of 'Aliyunwaluillah' is Sunnah and its not a part of Adhaan.
-Bibi Zaynab's Hijab was not removed and just the outside covering.
-Mohsen was killed in the attack of Omar against Syeda Zahra 's house.
Now Ayatollah Sistani's fatwa is:-
-Zanjir is Sunnah but in its boundaries (boundaries are stated in the maqtal).
-The shahadah of 'Aliyunwaluillah' is Sunnah and its not a part of Adhaan.
-Bibi Zaynab's Hijab was removed.
-Mohsen was killed in the attack of Omar against Syeda Zahra 's house.
Please sight the differences.
BUT DON'T CALL ANYBOSY KAFIR BECAUSE AYATOLLAH SISTANI WHOM KHOJAS SANCTIFY DOESN'T CALL HIS FELLOW ULEMAS KAFIR.
-Zanjir is Haraam.
-The shahadah of 'Aliyunwaliullah' is a good bida'h.
-Bibi Zaynab's Hijab was not removed and just the outside covering.
-Mohsen was not killed in the attack of Omar against the house of Zahra (sa).
Now the Moqaledin of Syed. Fadhlollah (among whom is Sheikh Salami) believe these beliefs and we have to respect their beliefs. But Syed. Shirazi (whom many Khojas and Iranians oppose and whom Kuweiti Aarbs follow) ruled out:-
-Zanjir is Sunnah (mustahhab).
-The shahadah of 'Aliyunwaluillah' is Sunnah and a matter of Istihbaab.
-Bibi Zaynab's Hijab was removed.
-Mohsen was killed in the attack of Omar against Syeda Zahra 's house.
As for Syed. khamaenei', he has ruled out that:-
-Zanjir is Haraam.
-The shahadah of 'Aliyunwaluillah' is Sunnah and its not a part of Adhaan.
-Bibi Zaynab's Hijab was not removed and just the outside covering.
-Mohsen was killed in the attack of Omar against Syeda Zahra 's house.
Now Ayatollah Sistani's fatwa is:-
-Zanjir is Sunnah but in its boundaries (boundaries are stated in the maqtal).
-The shahadah of 'Aliyunwaluillah' is Sunnah and its not a part of Adhaan.
-Bibi Zaynab's Hijab was removed.
-Mohsen was killed in the attack of Omar against Syeda Zahra 's house.
Please sight the differences.
BUT DON'T CALL ANYBOSY KAFIR BECAUSE AYATOLLAH SISTANI WHOM KHOJAS SANCTIFY DOESN'T CALL HIS FELLOW ULEMAS KAFIR.