- 29 Jan 2008, 23:56
#11572
you mention that the shaykh had clarified the issue of Hz Muhsin (AS) in public? This is news to me from you
As far as i know and even you know the said discussion had taken place between the shaykh and few momineens and thereafter there has been no clarifcation in public. As for the email which was posted here by sister fatimah (it was not done by shaykh)
as for the apology i think it should start from the shaykh to the few momineens he had discussed with, then others will follow because the shaykh has never contacted the people who , as per him, had misunderstood the discussion.
Were you present when the shaykh had discussed this issue? have you contacted the other side to know what he had said or what they had understood?
You say you are a witness to all this, i did not understand what you meant by being witness to all this.
I had told you in my previous replies also do not get excited dear brother
it is through discussions that people will understand each other.
Dont you think it would be advisable for the shaykh and the few momineens plus we (you, me, and others who are really interested) to have a sitting and discuss this matter for sorting the confusion?
May Allah through the grace of imam zamana (atfs) provide us with good guidance towards the truth.
wassalaam
band-e-ali wrote:salaam alaykumAsaalaam Alaykum,
..there are a majority of individuals that ACCTUALLY UNDERstood what he ment when he did clearify the Hz muhsin Isue in the Public!
you mention that the shaykh had clarified the issue of Hz Muhsin (AS) in public? This is news to me from you
As far as i know and even you know the said discussion had taken place between the shaykh and few momineens and thereafter there has been no clarifcation in public. As for the email which was posted here by sister fatimah (it was not done by shaykh)
brother hasin disagrees with it "being an after thought!" its natural to react in a way like that in anger! i realy dont know why u wrote somthing like this!- ever thought of the fact that ssheikh might be reading this aswell?- if the whole khoja shia isthinasheri jamaat has acess to this then? dont u think he needs an apology from you? if not physically then even if you do say it here? it still makes a diffrence?I understand the shaykh reads this.
as for the apology i think it should start from the shaykh to the few momineens he had discussed with, then others will follow because the shaykh has never contacted the people who , as per him, had misunderstood the discussion.
im quote'ng this and i want to make it really clear!
Sheikh Zaid did NOT say that muhsin was not exzistant!- its is a miss understanding caused by other people( i dont wish to mention names) and its not ffair that its coming down on sheikh like a ton of bricks.
Were you present when the shaykh had discussed this issue? have you contacted the other side to know what he had said or what they had understood?
You say you are a witness to all this, i did not understand what you meant by being witness to all this.
I had told you in my previous replies also do not get excited dear brother
it is through discussions that people will understand each other.
Dont you think it would be advisable for the shaykh and the few momineens plus we (you, me, and others who are really interested) to have a sitting and discuss this matter for sorting the confusion?
May Allah through the grace of imam zamana (atfs) provide us with good guidance towards the truth.
wassalaam