- 09 Feb 2008, 19:03
#11663
Salamun Alaikum,
Brother in islam, i ve been regularly following the very sensitive issue which has erupted in our community due to (as per my view) misunderstanding between the respected shaikh and our brothers .
we have to keep in mind one thing and that is not to lower any human beings as only Allah (S.w.t) has all the power.Coming back to the actual point i had an opportunity to have some lenthghy discussions with our guest , respected shaikh zaid and i asked him to eloboarte in details what he meant exactly in his very brief friday khutbas. He clarified and said he too beleives in the concept of wujud of h.Mohsin (a.s) about the veil of bibi Zainab (a.s) was snatched ? in reply he said only the face cover was snatched, and about praying behind the wahabi in haram e sharif (in mecca and Medina) he said even agha seestani Fatwa is in favour of what he said. zanjeer ,qama zani, he said he still do not agree as it defames islam.
So i told him the following about the rulings which are been thought to us by aalims who accompny us when u go for hajj (as he said he has never been to hajj) that in order to maintain unity amongst muslim we should join the congregation prayers which is lead by imam of other sect( wahabi) with furada niyyat and can recite the zikr of Allah (s.w.t) in order to maintain the muwallat .in that he did not reply anything.
coming to second point i told him that he might be right that zanjeer etc defames islam , and is not right to practice them but i suggested him although my knowledge about islam is very very litlle comapre to his knowledge but i have more experiance in knowing how our brothers rigidness , so i asked him to have more evidence to his claims in order to make our brothers understand that what they have been practicing for 70 to 100 years was wrong and should avoid in future.
Coming to the third point of Bibi Zainab (a.s) veil : As im now 30 years old i ve been hearing all my life whether from mimber or from other media that bibi were covering their respected face with their hairs during their journey from kerbala to sham.so i asked the respected shaikh and the zakirs who are completely opposite of each other to prove to the disintegrating dar es salaam comunity members . As far as zakirs are concern i know them as they get their source from the books writtem by aalims and ulemas who had done a very scrutinized research as they are responsible to Allah (s.w.t) and ahlul bait . for their writtings, so im sure and have full confidence in them , plz brother here i mean only those authentic ulemas which r considerd having (very high level of knowledge) in our shia faith.
I asked the shaikh to have an open discussion with the respected dsm community in order to clarify the issue as he has clarified to us so people who might have misunderstood him can understand him.
i even ask the zakirin to have a meeting with shaikh and with other interested members if they want to attend in order to share each other's view , thinking and knowledge at large/
I asked other members of the community not to propogate and lable thsi issue as a "big fight" etc We shia will never fight each other as our aim is one , we want to practice and spread the message of our imam Hussain (a.s) .
I asked the responsible people like brother Memboob Somji to arrange such kind of gathering so as to enable our members who r right now too much confused to remove their doubts.
As to prove your claim whether its shaikh or zakirs or any other person u need to have authentic and reliable source, historians are not always right Alhamdu lillah we have upto present very learned and pious ulemas where we can get all the answers we are looking for, so no space for doubts in our religious practices as its the only unique and right religion in the world.
Jazakallah, wasalaam. your brother in islam.
Brother in islam, i ve been regularly following the very sensitive issue which has erupted in our community due to (as per my view) misunderstanding between the respected shaikh and our brothers .
we have to keep in mind one thing and that is not to lower any human beings as only Allah (S.w.t) has all the power.Coming back to the actual point i had an opportunity to have some lenthghy discussions with our guest , respected shaikh zaid and i asked him to eloboarte in details what he meant exactly in his very brief friday khutbas. He clarified and said he too beleives in the concept of wujud of h.Mohsin (a.s) about the veil of bibi Zainab (a.s) was snatched ? in reply he said only the face cover was snatched, and about praying behind the wahabi in haram e sharif (in mecca and Medina) he said even agha seestani Fatwa is in favour of what he said. zanjeer ,qama zani, he said he still do not agree as it defames islam.
So i told him the following about the rulings which are been thought to us by aalims who accompny us when u go for hajj (as he said he has never been to hajj) that in order to maintain unity amongst muslim we should join the congregation prayers which is lead by imam of other sect( wahabi) with furada niyyat and can recite the zikr of Allah (s.w.t) in order to maintain the muwallat .in that he did not reply anything.
coming to second point i told him that he might be right that zanjeer etc defames islam , and is not right to practice them but i suggested him although my knowledge about islam is very very litlle comapre to his knowledge but i have more experiance in knowing how our brothers rigidness , so i asked him to have more evidence to his claims in order to make our brothers understand that what they have been practicing for 70 to 100 years was wrong and should avoid in future.
Coming to the third point of Bibi Zainab (a.s) veil : As im now 30 years old i ve been hearing all my life whether from mimber or from other media that bibi were covering their respected face with their hairs during their journey from kerbala to sham.so i asked the respected shaikh and the zakirs who are completely opposite of each other to prove to the disintegrating dar es salaam comunity members . As far as zakirs are concern i know them as they get their source from the books writtem by aalims and ulemas who had done a very scrutinized research as they are responsible to Allah (s.w.t) and ahlul bait . for their writtings, so im sure and have full confidence in them , plz brother here i mean only those authentic ulemas which r considerd having (very high level of knowledge) in our shia faith.
I asked the shaikh to have an open discussion with the respected dsm community in order to clarify the issue as he has clarified to us so people who might have misunderstood him can understand him.
i even ask the zakirin to have a meeting with shaikh and with other interested members if they want to attend in order to share each other's view , thinking and knowledge at large/
I asked other members of the community not to propogate and lable thsi issue as a "big fight" etc We shia will never fight each other as our aim is one , we want to practice and spread the message of our imam Hussain (a.s) .
I asked the responsible people like brother Memboob Somji to arrange such kind of gathering so as to enable our members who r right now too much confused to remove their doubts.
As to prove your claim whether its shaikh or zakirs or any other person u need to have authentic and reliable source, historians are not always right Alhamdu lillah we have upto present very learned and pious ulemas where we can get all the answers we are looking for, so no space for doubts in our religious practices as its the only unique and right religion in the world.
Jazakallah, wasalaam. your brother in islam.